Making these sweet little Greek honey cookies always makes me realize that it’s Christmas time! Melomakarona are one of the most popular treats in Greece during the Christmas Holidays with their intense homely smell full of cloves, cinnamon and nutmeg making every house smelling like Christmas!
These sweet little Greek honey cookies (melomakarona) are super quick to bake, so much fun to make and highly addictive! My traditional Greek melomakarona recipe makes 50 of these delicious, festive Greek Christmas cookies, plenty for everyone to try.
So go ahead, read on to discover how to make my traditional Melomakarona to perfection with my tips and tricks, step by step photos, my chocolate variation, how to store and serve them and of course the recipe!
Melomakarona recipe – A delicious Greek Christmas tradition
Melomakarona are my absolute favourite Greek Christmas cookies. And how couldn’t they be? These cookies are incredibly soft, moist, flavorsome, and soaked in a delicious honey syrup. Once baked, the intense aromas of the cloves, cinnamon and nutmeg spread throughout the house and bring back plenty of fond childhood memories!
What does “melomakarono” mean?
Melomakarona (μελομακάρονα) are traditional Greek Christmas cookies, that are served during Christmas time throughout Greece. The word “melomakarona” is a combination of the two words “meli”, which means honey and “makarona”. “Makarona” comes from the ancient word “makaria” and means blessed.
In the olden days, Melomakarona used to be served on the lead up to Christmas as a Lenten “kerasma” (treat) to enjoy during fasting. Since they have no egg or dairy, Melomakarona are vegan and perfect if you are fasting or are on a vegan diet!
Finally, in some regions of Greece “melomakarona” are also called “finikia”. The traditional recipe for melomakarona and finikia is pretty much the same, with the only difference that finikia are deep fried instead of baked.
How to make the best Greek Christmas honey cookies / Melomakarona?
Making traditional Greek Melomakarona is not difficult at all, but you must pay attention to the following little details.
Don’t overwork the dough
Always dunk the hot Melomakarona in cold syrup
Use semolina in the dough
Preparing the Melomakarona dough
When preparing the Melomakarona dough, it is important not to overwork it. If you mix the dough for too long it will cause the oil to separate from the mixture and result in a cookie that has a very oily taste. Just knead lightly with your hands or a spoon until the flour has incorporated and the dough is really soft.
Also always make and bake your Melomakarona on the same day. If you store the dough in the fridge to bake later, the oil will also separate from the mixture. So set aside about 1 hour, get your melomakarona ingredients ready and let’s bake!
Finally, don’t add any more flour than this melomakarona recipe calls for, as this will make the cookies tough. If the dough is too sticky let it rest for a few minutes and try handling it again. If it is still too sticky, then add a little bit of extra flour. Take a look at my picture below, which shows what the dough texture should be.
Dunking your Melomakarona in the syrup
The fragrant syrup is the essence of Melomakarona. To make sure your Melomakarona soak the syrup all the way in, you need to dunk the piping hot Melomakarona, straight from the oven in a cold or room temperature syrup. This will help the cookies to absorb the syrup and become moist on the inside.
So always start by making your syrup first. When the syrup is ready, take it off the hob and let it cool down. Then start making your Melomakarona dough. That way it will have cooled down by the time your first batch of Melomakarona is ready.
If you are in a hurry, you can put the syrup in the fridge to cool down, while you are preparing the dough for the melomakarona. Just make sure you place your syrup pot on an oven mitt so your fridge shelves don’t crack!
Finally, you’ll need to soak your melomakarona in the syrup for long enough for the syrup to soak through. If you love your Melomakarona juicy and moist, let them soak up a bit more syrup up – 20 seconds in the syrup should do it! To speed up the dunking, bake them in batches so when one cooks the other is dunked in the honey syrup.
Semolina – the secret ingredient to juicier Melomakarona
Have you ever wondered why some Melomakarona are juicier while others taste more like biscuits? It’s because the juicier Melomakarona have some fine semolina in the dough!
Semolina is made from ground up durum wheat and has a very high water absorption ratio. No wonder it is used to make pasta, couscous as well as the traditional Greek halva (semolina cake).
So adding some semolina to the melomakarona mixture will ensure that the dough is more absorbent and will soak up and retain a lot more of the honey syrup. This will make your melomakarona deliciously soft on the inside while also slightly crunchy on the outside!
Melomakarona variations
My favourite variation to the traditional Melomakarona, are Melomakarona covered in chocolate! The bitterness of the chocolate perfectly complements the sweetness of the Melomakarona and makes them even more irresistible! So, if you have a knack for chocolate these are made for you!
Keeping your Melomakarona fresh – How long will they keep?
If want to bake a large batch of Melomakarona or want to have some around for your guests this holiday season you are in luck!
As the honey in the syrup has antimicrobial properties, melomakarona will keep fresh for around 2-3 weeks if stored properly. Just make sure you store them in an airtight container and at room temperature.
So go ahead, try out my traditional Greek melomakarona recipe together with a cup of Greek coffee and let the smell of freshly baked cookies, orange, clove, and cinnamon remind you it’s Christmas! Enjoy!
A traditional melomakarona recipe! These Greek Christmas honey cookies (melomakarona) are super quick to bake, so much fun to make and highly addictive!
To prepare this melomakarona recipe start by making the syrup first. In a pot add all the ingredients for the syrup, besides the honey and bring to the boil. Boil for 3-4 minutes, until the sugar has dissolved and remove from the stove. Stir in the honey and set aside to cool completely.
Prepare the dough for the melomakarona. In a bowl add the semolina, flour and baking powder and mix with a whisk to combine.
In another large bowl add the orangejuice, the cognac, the sugar and spices (nutmeg, cinnamon, clove, vanilla) and mix. Add the baking soda and whisk immediately for 5-10 seconds until the ingredients combine and the baking soda dissolves and starts to foam. Pour in the bowl the water, the oil, the orange zest and honey and whisk to combine.
Now it’s time to combine the two mixtures. Add the mixed flour, semolina and baking powder (from step 2) in the bowl with the rest of the ingredients from step 3 and start kneading the dough for the melomakarona. Knead the dough for the melomakarona using your hands, until the ingredients combine and the dough is smooth and soft and slightly sticky. Be careful not to overwork the dough as they will become tough.
Preheat the oven at 180C / 356F. Layer the bottom of 4 large baking trays with parchment paper and start shaping the melomakarona. Pinch a portion of dough about the size of a walnut – 30g / 1oz and shape with your palms into a smooth oblong shape, like a small egg. Place on the baking tray, push lightly the top with a fork and pierce three times on top about half way through the dough. Continue with the rest of the dough.
Depending on how large on oven you have when your first two trays are ready you can start baking them. Place the baking trays with the melomakarona in the oven and bake for approx. 15-20 minutes, until the melomakarona are lightly and evenly browned and cooked through. If you’ve made them bigger, you’ll need to bump up the cooking time!!
When the melomakarona come out of the oven, dip them immediately in the cold syrup, flipping them with a slotted spoon to absorb the syrup for approx. 10-20 seconds, depending on how syrupy you like them. Remove the cookies using a slotted spoon, place on a platter and sprinkle with chopped walnuts.
While you are dipping your first couple of tray in the syrup add the next two in the oven to bake. Don’t forget to set your timer!!
Store the melomakarona at room temperature in an airtight container. They will keep for all your Christmas Holidays!
Hi Rita, oh no, let me see what could have happened:
1. Possibly the flour was sifted and then weighed? Should weigh the flour before sifting
2. Used a mixer by any chance or kneaded the dough for too long? If yes, gluten has developed and made the dough hard / almost bread like.
3. Did you use bread flour by any chance? Should be using normal, plain flour
4. Possibly the cup was too small? It should be 250ml for a cup and if the dough feels a bit dry try adding a little extra oil mixture….
Thank you for this recipe I made it and followed it to a T and the tradional melomakarona came out perfectly just like my yaiyai used to make. It made my family very happy and nostalgic thank you.
Thats what I always do every year, make them about 2 weeks before Christmas and they are just fine for the whole holiday season. The problem is that they are never enough and they usually get eaten up pretty quickly!
No it’s okay, they last a long time, also I’ve put them in the freezer before adding the honey, actually taste better ,when ready remove from freezer make syrup, make sure syrup is hot and dip each cookie in syrup
The description says “infused with fragrant butter”. I read the recipe three times and see no butter called for… Just want to make them correctly and can’t wait to try this out!
I am having a hard time using the exact amount as is in the recipe because when I convert to cups it doesn’t give me the right amount…. Is there an easier way?
In my 50 years + of baking I have found that a good kitchen scale is worth its value in gold for certain recipes! (I noted that your post was made in April 2015 BUT also noted that no one had responded!)
This recipe is perfect, I used Kalymnian thyme honey and Iliada kalamata extra vergin olive oil… They were the best that ever came out of my oven. Instead of cognac I used grand marnier liqeur and I had fresh oranges, the ingredients really made the difference I think!
Great recipe except I was left over with lots of syrup and 20 mins was a little too long for me. I think I will make half the amount of syrup next time. Left over syrup is my incentive to make another batch 🙂
I made these on Saturday for our Greek Orthodox Easter, I doubled the recipe and made 65 good sized biscuits.
These biscuits caused a stir in my family, first my daughter ate 3 before we ate, my brother in law said that they were the BEST melomakarona he has ever had and his mother is a fabulous baker, I ended up breaking two up over really good vanilla ice cream and mixing it through which was heavenly to eat.
I did change the recipe slightly, I used olive oil, I didn’t use vegetable oil as most traditional Greek recipes never call for vegetable oil and next time I will use less than the 250ml stated. But in saying that, I thank you for sharing a beautiful recipe that will now continue down the generations to come!
I tried them and indeed very nice tasting. Dud not use olive oil because our variety in South Africa is not at all like the Greek ones in Greece and boy do I miss Greek honey! The best tasting honey around. Pity one cannot import Greek honey!
Thank you! I found your veg moussaka recipe, loved it…now I see your Melamakarona look exactly like my yaya’s, tears in my eyes, I couldn’t find her recipe for so long. I’m so grateful ?
This is my first try of Melomacarona. The dough somehow became a bit runny. I added some more flour. It was still a bit runny but I shaped them with a bit of difficulty. I couldn’t even fork them. Anyways it turned out soooo well that all 45 cookies finished in 2 days. Maybe the oranges yielded a lot of juice. I wish the measurement was in cups.
It sounds like the liquids where a bit on the high side or the flour used was less absorbent than the one I made them with :). Its OK, measurements don’t need to be exact, just make sure the texture is right, similar to the photos I’ve got in the end of the recipe and they will turn out great!
A digital scale is what you need. Metric is so much more precise. A cup of flour can vary by a LOT depending on things like how you scoop it into the cup, whether it’s been packed down in your container, or if you whisked it before measuring. Using a digital scale and measuring in grams means no confusion. You know you made the recipe the way the author intended. Also, if you want to double or halve the recipe, it’s a lot easier using metric.
Thank you so much for the recipe!
I cooked walnut sized cookies for 15 mins.. the bottoms were browned and the tops were slightly browning. Now that they are finished, I find the inside to be quite moist (which is great) however they seem almost not cooked! I’m not sure if they are meant to be an almost “uncooked” texture in the middle? I’ve never had them before!
Thanks!
Hi Jasmine, the cookies meant to be soft in the middle due to the high oil content in the dough; they are not meant to be crunchy like your usual biscuits so from your comment I think you’re fine.
Next time you make them though try using a higher rack setting in your oven and fan assist if available to get them to be more even in terms of colour.
Ideally you need the top to be evenly light golden brown coloured and not pale. It takes roughly 15-20 minutes if your cookies are small, flat and pierced with a fork like the ones in my pictures 🙂
Hi Eve, I prefer not using cups as they vary so much and are less accurate than grams/ounces. In any case, I’ve added the ingredients in cups for you 🙂
I made this recipe last weekend and followed it exactly as it is written. Unfortunately many who tried my cookies complained the texture was grainy, almost like a sandy texture. I compared it to cornbread. Please give me advice on how to fix this. I used the fine semolina flour as well.
They may have needed a little bit longer in the syrup to soak it up and for the semolina to soften. Also possibly reduce the baking time just by a few minutes – the cookies need to be just about browned on the outside.
I tried this and I absolutely love this – thank you for sharing this! 🙂
My only concern is that my cookies did not brown like the pictures in your recipe. I did bake them thoroughly as they did get slightly brown on the outside but not as dark as your image. Any tips on what could have caused that?
For the soft flour I used cake flour because that’s the only soft flour I had on hand. Is it ok to use all purpose flour instead?
Firstly, dont sub the veg oil with olive oil as they will become too heavy on the taste. Olive oil is very strong flavour wise.
Flour wise, yes, of course, all purpose flour is perfect!
Regarding the color, they should be a tiny bit brown when they come out of the oven and then when you dunk them in the syrup they will darken up like the images above 🙂
This is a wonderful recipe. Easy to follow, measurements are exact, and the end result is delicious! Thank you so much for sharing! Kala Christougenna!
Please can you tell me: the Liquids (in this recepie) are measured in grams? Not in litres??? So we need 100g of orange juce – NOT 100 ml ?? This is very important please
Thank You
I loved this recipe! I am trying to recreate the cookies I remember from my childhood; my mother and yaya died when I was very young so I don’t have anyone to consult with! Their honey cookies were more dense and not as soft – I’m thinking maybe they used more semolina flour in them? Or is there another Greek cookie that is in a honey bath besides these? Thanks for your help!
Best recipe ever! I took “soft flour” to mean cake flour, used fine semolina, weighed everything, fresh squeezed OJ. I love cooking with cognac, and I even put some in the cookies
My mother was from Greece. She always dipped the hot cookies in boiling syrup, not cold syrup. Then would dip them in a mixture of pecans, sugar and cinnamon. I make them every year following her recipe which is similar to yours except for the cold syrup.
I have lost my original recipe, unfortunately your recipe had far too much oil! The mixture was swimming in oil, I’ve added more flour, but they’re extremely soft. Thanks anyway
I tried making these for the first time two days ago and they came out beautifully. Thank you for your clear, detailed instructions – they take the stress out of baking. I now have the confidence to try more traditional recipes!
I found the measurements very confusing. I’m not familiar with metric measurements so the conversions didn’t seem correct. The flour says 17.6 ounces or 4 cups. This can’t be right. 4 cups is 32 ounces. And too much flour would definitely ruin the recipe. Can you clarify?
This is my second year making this particular recipe and the cookies come out amazing. My only thing is I don’t need 8 cups and a little more liquid like some more orange juice would be perfect. They came out fluffy moist in the middle and nice and crunchy on the outside before adding the syrup so good.
Merry Christmas
I made these for the second year in a row and no it wasn’t a fluke. They are the best melomakarona ever. Even my mom, who used to make them, loves them. 1 2x the recipe. Yummm. The dough was perfect. I measured using cups and it worked out great. Put a little less sugar in the syrup.
Just about to make this recipe but your measurement conversions don’t make sense. 150 grams of semolina flour is just under a cup, not a half a cup. I checked several sources, and they all vary somewhat from just below a cup to a cup. When I measured my semolina on my scale it came to just under a cup, so you are definitley off with the 1/2 cup conversion. I will go by texture more than exact flour amounts and hope for the best. But consider rechecking your conversions. thanks
Question! When you say “soft flour”, do you mean pastry flour? Cake flour? Or is there a specific protein percentage you go for? Please help as I definitely want to make these for this Christmas! Thank you so much!
Over the past 8 years you have made My Greek Dish the number one destination for anyone searching for authentic Greek recipes! For that I cannot thank you enough!
It all started with an idea… To collate and publish all those recipes that I loved when I was young, the ones I made with so much love for my children and grand children!
So go ahead, explore my delicious collections and don’t forget to leave me a comment, connect with me on Facebook or Instagram and sign up to my mailing list so you never miss out on my latest creations!
(1,133 votes, average: 4.84 out of 5)
Loading...
How many does this make????
We’ve got about 50 pieces out of this recipe. But it all depends on how big you make them 🙂
Recipe didn’t work out for me. Dough too dry to work with, and did follow all instructions step by step…:(
Hi Rita, oh no, let me see what could have happened:
1. Possibly the flour was sifted and then weighed? Should weigh the flour before sifting
2. Used a mixer by any chance or kneaded the dough for too long? If yes, gluten has developed and made the dough hard / almost bread like.
3. Did you use bread flour by any chance? Should be using normal, plain flour
4. Possibly the cup was too small? It should be 250ml for a cup and if the dough feels a bit dry try adding a little extra oil mixture….
The dough needs more liquids. I use 1 and1/4 cups of orange juice and 1/2 cup of brandy in 3 pounds of flour. Yield 93 pieces.
Thank you very much, these turned out amazing. I hadn’t had melomakarona since I left Greece 10 years ago!
Thank you for this recipe I made it and followed it to a T and the tradional melomakarona came out perfectly just like my yaiyai used to make. It made my family very happy and nostalgic thank you.
Hi Eli Katerina – If I made these in the next few days 8th Dec would them keep until christmas or am I better to make them closer to the time?
Thats what I always do every year, make them about 2 weeks before Christmas and they are just fine for the whole holiday season. The problem is that they are never enough and they usually get eaten up pretty quickly!
Love
Eli
No it’s okay, they last a long time, also I’ve put them in the freezer before adding the honey, actually taste better ,when ready remove from freezer make syrup, make sure syrup is hot and dip each cookie in syrup
For the butter do you use salted or unsalted butter ?
Hi Pota
Its unsalted butter.
Love
Eli
The description says “infused with fragrant butter”. I read the recipe three times and see no butter called for… Just want to make them correctly and can’t wait to try this out!
I am having a hard time using the exact amount as is in the recipe because when I convert to cups it doesn’t give me the right amount…. Is there an easier way?
In my 50 years + of baking I have found that a good kitchen scale is worth its value in gold for certain recipes! (I noted that your post was made in April 2015 BUT also noted that no one had responded!)
This recipe is perfect, I used Kalymnian thyme honey and Iliada kalamata extra vergin olive oil… They were the best that ever came out of my oven. Instead of cognac I used grand marnier liqeur and I had fresh oranges, the ingredients really made the difference I think!
Great recipe except I was left over with lots of syrup and 20 mins was a little too long for me. I think I will make half the amount of syrup next time. Left over syrup is my incentive to make another batch 🙂
I made these on Saturday for our Greek Orthodox Easter, I doubled the recipe and made 65 good sized biscuits.
These biscuits caused a stir in my family, first my daughter ate 3 before we ate, my brother in law said that they were the BEST melomakarona he has ever had and his mother is a fabulous baker, I ended up breaking two up over really good vanilla ice cream and mixing it through which was heavenly to eat.
I did change the recipe slightly, I used olive oil, I didn’t use vegetable oil as most traditional Greek recipes never call for vegetable oil and next time I will use less than the 250ml stated. But in saying that, I thank you for sharing a beautiful recipe that will now continue down the generations to come!
I tried them and indeed very nice tasting. Dud not use olive oil because our variety in South Africa is not at all like the Greek ones in Greece and boy do I miss Greek honey! The best tasting honey around. Pity one cannot import Greek honey!
Thank you! I found your veg moussaka recipe, loved it…now I see your Melamakarona look exactly like my yaya’s, tears in my eyes, I couldn’t find her recipe for so long. I’m so grateful ?
Made this the other day. Simply amazing! Loved how soft and juicy these turned out to be!
This is my first try of Melomacarona. The dough somehow became a bit runny. I added some more flour. It was still a bit runny but I shaped them with a bit of difficulty. I couldn’t even fork them. Anyways it turned out soooo well that all 45 cookies finished in 2 days. Maybe the oranges yielded a lot of juice. I wish the measurement was in cups.
Hi Hatice,
It sounds like the liquids where a bit on the high side or the flour used was less absorbent than the one I made them with :). Its OK, measurements don’t need to be exact, just make sure the texture is right, similar to the photos I’ve got in the end of the recipe and they will turn out great!
Best regards
Eli
A digital scale is what you need. Metric is so much more precise. A cup of flour can vary by a LOT depending on things like how you scoop it into the cup, whether it’s been packed down in your container, or if you whisked it before measuring. Using a digital scale and measuring in grams means no confusion. You know you made the recipe the way the author intended. Also, if you want to double or halve the recipe, it’s a lot easier using metric.
I fully agree! Cups are useful for liquids but for solids, it can vary a lot, especially with flour!
Hi, I made it for the first time. They are fabolous! I follow the reciepe and changed the orange juice with orange syrup, home made. Extra!
So glad you liked it Ula! Merry Christmas to you :)!
Thank you so much for the recipe!
I cooked walnut sized cookies for 15 mins.. the bottoms were browned and the tops were slightly browning. Now that they are finished, I find the inside to be quite moist (which is great) however they seem almost not cooked! I’m not sure if they are meant to be an almost “uncooked” texture in the middle? I’ve never had them before!
Thanks!
Hi Jasmine, the cookies meant to be soft in the middle due to the high oil content in the dough; they are not meant to be crunchy like your usual biscuits so from your comment I think you’re fine.
Next time you make them though try using a higher rack setting in your oven and fan assist if available to get them to be more even in terms of colour.
Ideally you need the top to be evenly light golden brown coloured and not pale. It takes roughly 15-20 minutes if your cookies are small, flat and pierced with a fork like the ones in my pictures 🙂
Merry Christmas!
Eli
What can I use instead of honey to make them vegan friendly? 🙂
Hi Effie, you can bump up the sugar slightly and skip honey altogether!
Can someone please convert the ingredients into cups? ???? thanks!
We use our Alexa to do that! ????
Hi Eve, I prefer not using cups as they vary so much and are less accurate than grams/ounces. In any case, I’ve added the ingredients in cups for you 🙂
I’ve been making this recipe, every year, since 2015! Never failed me! It’s brilliant! Thanks a lot!
I’ve been eating them every year since 2015 and I can confirm their brilliance!
Your welcome R! So glad you like it and keep coming back to make it 🙂
So excited to use this recipe today. It was so well written and described. I believe it will turn out great.
Thank you Addie! I’m sure you will love them ❤️
I made this recipe last weekend and followed it exactly as it is written. Unfortunately many who tried my cookies complained the texture was grainy, almost like a sandy texture. I compared it to cornbread. Please give me advice on how to fix this. I used the fine semolina flour as well.
They may have needed a little bit longer in the syrup to soak it up and for the semolina to soften. Also possibly reduce the baking time just by a few minutes – the cookies need to be just about browned on the outside.
Hi, I’m wondering how to use the “orange cut in half” for the syrup. Does that mean to juice a half an orange and use its juice in the syrup? Thanks.
Its as simple as it sounds 🙂 Cut an orange in half and add the half orange in the syrup. Don’t juice it, peel it etc, just add it as it is.
I like it!! I love trying new types of food!
Hi! If I omit the cognac does it make a difference? I will be making half of the recipe because 50 cookies are too many for my household! 🙂
I tried this and I absolutely love this – thank you for sharing this! 🙂
My only concern is that my cookies did not brown like the pictures in your recipe. I did bake them thoroughly as they did get slightly brown on the outside but not as dark as your image. Any tips on what could have caused that?
For the soft flour I used cake flour because that’s the only soft flour I had on hand. Is it ok to use all purpose flour instead?
Can I sub the vegetable oil with olive oil?
Hey G
Firstly, dont sub the veg oil with olive oil as they will become too heavy on the taste. Olive oil is very strong flavour wise.
Flour wise, yes, of course, all purpose flour is perfect!
Regarding the color, they should be a tiny bit brown when they come out of the oven and then when you dunk them in the syrup they will darken up like the images above 🙂
Thank you for the wonderful recipe.
Can I make the syrup the day before and leave it on the fridge for the night?
Thanks for the help
Yeap absolutely you can!
This is a wonderful recipe. Easy to follow, measurements are exact, and the end result is delicious! Thank you so much for sharing! Kala Christougenna!
Your welcome Thespina! So glad you loved it!!
Please can you tell me: the Liquids (in this recepie) are measured in grams? Not in litres??? So we need 100g of orange juce – NOT 100 ml ?? This is very important please
Thank You
Yeap its 100 grams 🙂
I loved this recipe! I am trying to recreate the cookies I remember from my childhood; my mother and yaya died when I was very young so I don’t have anyone to consult with! Their honey cookies were more dense and not as soft – I’m thinking maybe they used more semolina flour in them? Or is there another Greek cookie that is in a honey bath besides these? Thanks for your help!
Thank you very much, these turned out amazing. I hadn’t had melomakarona since I left Greece 10 years ago
Best recipe ever! I took “soft flour” to mean cake flour, used fine semolina, weighed everything, fresh squeezed OJ. I love cooking with cognac, and I even put some in the cookies
what can you add instead of cognac
Brandy is the alternative for this 🙂
My mother was from Greece. She always dipped the hot cookies in boiling syrup, not cold syrup. Then would dip them in a mixture of pecans, sugar and cinnamon. I make them every year following her recipe which is similar to yours except for the cold syrup.
I have lost my original recipe, unfortunately your recipe had far too much oil! The mixture was swimming in oil, I’ve added more flour, but they’re extremely soft. Thanks anyway
I tried making these for the first time two days ago and they came out beautifully. Thank you for your clear, detailed instructions – they take the stress out of baking. I now have the confidence to try more traditional recipes!
I found the measurements very confusing. I’m not familiar with metric measurements so the conversions didn’t seem correct. The flour says 17.6 ounces or 4 cups. This can’t be right. 4 cups is 32 ounces. And too much flour would definitely ruin the recipe. Can you clarify?
Thank you for my fav recipe
How long do they last at room temp please and if you refrigerate do they longer?
Thank you
Katherine
Can I make the cookies first and soak in syrup at a later date? In other words, how do I soak cold cookies in cold syrup
This is my second year making this particular recipe and the cookies come out amazing. My only thing is I don’t need 8 cups and a little more liquid like some more orange juice would be perfect. They came out fluffy moist in the middle and nice and crunchy on the outside before adding the syrup so good.
Merry Christmas
I made these for the second year in a row and no it wasn’t a fluke. They are the best melomakarona ever. Even my mom, who used to make them, loves them. 1 2x the recipe. Yummm. The dough was perfect. I measured using cups and it worked out great. Put a little less sugar in the syrup.
Just about to make this recipe but your measurement conversions don’t make sense. 150 grams of semolina flour is just under a cup, not a half a cup. I checked several sources, and they all vary somewhat from just below a cup to a cup. When I measured my semolina on my scale it came to just under a cup, so you are definitley off with the 1/2 cup conversion. I will go by texture more than exact flour amounts and hope for the best. But consider rechecking your conversions. thanks
This is a great recipe however I do like a crispier cookie. What can I change/add to make it crispier?
Thank you!
Question! When you say “soft flour”, do you mean pastry flour? Cake flour? Or is there a specific protein percentage you go for? Please help as I definitely want to make these for this Christmas! Thank you so much!